Vishaka George

Sharmila Joshi

Editor

large_01-IMG_20180105_144146-VG-When_the_man_knows_you_but_the_machine_doesnt.jpg

medium_01-IMG_20180105_144146-VG-When_the_man_knows_you_but_the_machine_doesnt.jpg

small_01-IMG_20180105_144146-VG-When_the_man_knows_you_but_the_machine_doesnt.jpg

thumbnail_01-IMG_20180105_144146-VG-When_the_man_knows_you_but_the_machine_doesnt.jpg

01-IMG_20180105_144146-VG-When_the_man_knows_you_but_the_machine_doesnt.jpg

The lane to her house is an upward slope, one
which Aadhilakshmi, 72, finds hard to climb after a leg surgery last year.  The home in a slum colony in Bhavani Nagar, in
the Suddagunte Palya area of south
Bengaluru, is a single room
that she shares with six other family members.

Aadhilakshmi and her husband Kunnaiah Ram, 83,
migrated to Bengaluru around 30 years ago from a village in Madurai district,
Tamil Nadu, in search of work. While he found a job as a carpenter, she raised
their two sons and two daughters.  “Just because I am old does that mean I do not need to eat?” she asks. It’s a question she has repeated an unfortunate number of times in the last six months when she and her husband were denied their rations – seven kilos of free rice per person per month.  The subsidised salt, sugar, palm oil and soap they got in addition to the rice, for which they had to pay Rs. 150, has also stopped.  Why was the elderly couple denied their rations? For both, fingerprint authentication failed at the PDS outlet they regularly visit around two kilometres from their home. Small machines that are supposed to do the job have been installed in these ration shops in Bengaluru – there are around 1,800 such outlets in the city.

In the city and across India, Aadhaar details have been linked or “seeded” into ration cards, and every time people go to collect their monthly rations, they must submit their fingerprints as proof of identity. Reports vary about when linking below the poverty line (BPL) ration cards with Aadhaar became mandatory in Karnataka, though the deadline seems to have been June 2017. This potentially impacts around 8 million (estimates vary) BPL card holders in the state. Karnataka’s minister for Food and Public Distribution, U.T. Khader, has reportedly told presspersons that ration cards not linked to Aadhaar would be treated as &#39;bogus&#39;.  However, when the Aadhaar identity system was launched in 2009, it was meant to be an &quot;optional” programme to help streamline the PDS. Over time though, linkages to Aadhaar have been made mandatory to avail various government schemes such as LPG connections and scholarships. The Aadhaar ID number is also being linked to multiple services, including bank accounts and mobile phone connections provided even by private operators. The flaws in such a system, and the potential for fraud and for massive state surveillance of Indian citizens are only some of the growing criticisms, and the Supreme Court of India is presently hearing  a slew of petitions that challenge the constitutional validity of Aadhaar. Meanwhile,
despite managing to get their Aadhaar cards in early 2016,  Kunnaiah Ram and Aadhilakshmi  are at a loss. “We were told to go back and
get enrolled again [repeat the fingerprinting process at an Aadhaar centre] because
we are old and our fingerprints
do not match [with the machine in the ration shop],” says Kunnaiah Ram. 

But here is another problem: “You are supposed
to use your fingerprint to enrol. That fingerprint then becomes your password
to authenticate yourself to access benefits. However, the technology does not
recognise that manual labourers have flawed fingerprints by virtue of the work
they do, or that ageing can result in fingerprint changes,” explains Vidushi
Marda, a legal researcher with Article
19, a global human rights
organisation, who
previously worked with The Centre for Internet and Society in Bengaluru. “The
Aadhaar system uses an inherently problematic technology for the very set of
people it claims to save.”

Aadhilakshmi and Kunnaiah Ram live with their eldest son, a construction worker, who has a wife and three children (their
younger son is a carpenter who lives separately). 

“It’s a loss of dignity for us to still rely on
our son. He has three children to feed and educate. Why should they have to
split their share of rations with us?” asks a helpless Aadhilakshmi. 

Their old age pensions of Rs. 500 each get
swallowed every month by health-related expenses.  Aadhilakshmi recently had a cataract surgery
and is recovering from an accident that broke her leg. Kunnaiah Ram has a heart
ailment, weak knees, and often suffers dizzy spells. 

A ration shop
attendant I spoke to, who asked to not be named, said that the BPL card should
suffice in the case of very old people. However, one member of the family must
authenticate his or her fingerprints.  So
what happens when both, husband and wife, do not have matched biometrics? 

“Even if I have known them for a long time, I
cannot issue them rations if they fail the machine test,” says the attendant.
“They just have to get re-enrolled and the fingerprints must match. They must go
to government offices such as the Food and Civil Supplies department, the
Bangalore Development Authority or other enrolment centres and re-enrol,” she
says.  No one has a clue about what
should be done if, as almost inevitable, the fingerprint failure repeats
itself. It’s the same fingers, after all.

Aadhilakshmi struggles to walk up a less than 10-foot slope to her home. How does the state expect such citizens to then run around the city just to authenticate themselves? “Millions of Indians with Aadhaar numbers – senior citizens, children, the disabled and those who do physical labour, are forced to live with the grim reality of their biometrics not being recognised by the machines. This technocratic system has no idea of how to set the problem right. So the affected must run to different offices to prove who they are,” says Kshithij Urs, a Right to Food activist and professor at the National Law College, Bengaluru.Less than 200 metres
away from Aadhilakshmi’s home, Vijaylakshmi, once a construction worker and now an elderly vegetable vendor, has also not got her rations for over a year: another blotched biometric test. “I have tried to sort out the problem twice, but with no luck,” she says. The Rs. 150 Vijaylakshmi earns daily selling vegetables helps her make ends meet. It’s not just the elderly and manual labourers paying the price for Aadhaar’s technological incompetence.  Children do, too.

At a home in a slum situated in the hustle of Cottonpet bazaar, west Bengaluru, siblings Kishore, 14, and Keerthana, 13, have not received their share of rations for two years because of non-matching biometric data. If a child is enrolled before 15, she/he must repeat the process when they reach that age. What if the biometrics do not match in the interim though? Well, you don’t get your rations. Their parents are municipal corporation sweepers, whose combined salaries total Rs. 12,000 a month. Kishore, a bright student, joined a private English medium school two years ago, but mounting expenses and the ration denial forced his parents to pull him out and enrol him in a government school. He now helps with the family income by delivering milk in his neighbourhood.  He wakes up at 4 a.m. and leaves home at 6 a.m. to deliver morning supplies.  He then rushes to school at 9 a.m. After school closes at 4 p.m., he darts off to make the evening milk deliveries. His work day ends at 8 p.m. But what about homework? “I try to finish as much of it as I can in school,” says Kishore. The roughly eight hours of work he clocks in every day earns him Rs. 3,500, all of which he gives to his parents. With the added income, they can handle the family’s provisions.  Often, they buy rice from their neighbours at Rs. 15 a kilogram. But if the two children could also get their rations, seven kilos of rice would have been free for each of them.  It hardly matters that they have been going to the same ration shop for years because, says Reshma, an activist with the Right to Food campaign, “the dealer may know you, but the machine does not.”

When the man knows you, the machine doesn’t

ਬੰਦੇ ਦੇ ਪਛਾਣਿਆਂ ਗੱਲ ਨਹੀਂ ਬਣਦੀ, ਮਸ਼ੀਨ ਦਾ ਪਛਾਣਨਾ ਜ਼ਰੂਰੀ

‘മനുഷ്യർക്ക് നിങ്ങളെ മനസ്സിലാക്കാം, പക്ഷെ യന്ത്രങ്ങൾക്ക് കഴിയില്ല’

மனிதர் உங்களை அறியலாம், இயந்திரம் அப்படியானதல்ல

ಮನುಷ್ಯರು ನಿಮ್ಮನ್ನು ಗುರುತಿಸಬಲ್ಲರೇ ಹೊರತು, ಯಂತ್ರಗಳು ಗುರುತಿಸಲಾರವು...

ମଣିଷ ଚିହ୍ନନ୍ତି କିନ୍ତୁ ମେସିନ୍ ଚିହ୍ନେନି

মানুহে চিনিলেও মেচিনে নিচিনে

दुकानदार तुम्हाला ओळखेल हो, पण यंत्राला नाही ना कळत

মানুষ চিনলেও, যন্ত্রের কাছে আপনি অচেনা

अगर मशीन ने आपको नहीं पहचाना, तो राशन नहीं मिलेगा

جب آدمی آپ کو پہچانتا ہے، مشین نہیں

Bengaluru

At present, we can only accept donations in Indian rupees by Indian citizens. All donations made to the CounterMedia Trust are eligible for exemption under Section 80G of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Here is a copy of our exemption certificate.


India is bigger than New Delhi. And people need to know more about the rest of this vast nation.


Younger, media-saturated generations are growing up knowing little about their country, but a lot about the elites of a few metros and towns. For a narrowly-owned, commercially-driven media, the dumbing down of a nation is part of standard operating procedure. The last available data of the Centre for Media Studies (CMS, Delhi) show us that reports from New Delhi account for 66 per cent of news on the front pages of major dailies. The CMS data also found that just about 0.24 per cent of front page news came out of rural India. The TV channels are not much better.PARI exists to change that.We are a non-profit organisation. We publish under creative commons, and do not charge readers a subscription fee or put-up advertisements. Nothing is behind a paywall and we are completely free-to-access by anyone. We guard our independence and receive no direct grants from governments and corporations, nor any funding that could dictate our content. So, we are dependent on volunteer labour, donations from individuals, foundations and institutions that see value in independent and free media.PARI is changing the way Indian journalism reports and documents the rural.India is more than the elite of a few metros and towns. We report on rural lives and livelihoods, languages, communities, migrants and more. We need your help to pull off this most ambitious of Indian journalistic endeavours. The scale of this effort costs money. Donate generously - and spread the word about PARI.&nbsp;

Donate FAQs


Let’s get you acquainted

Welcome to PARI

All our content is, and will forever be free to consume. If you enjoy our work, you can support us by becoming a volunteer or by donating to help fund our work.

Want to republish this article? Please write to <a href="mailto:zahra@ruralindiaonline.org" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">zahra@ruralindiaonline.org</a> with a cc to <a href="mailto:namita@ruralindiaonline.org" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">namita@ruralindiaonline.org</a>

When the man knows you, the machine doesn’t

The elderly, migrants, daily wage workers, even children in Bengaluru’s slums are among those being denied their monthly rations due to fingerprint mismatches – and in their battles with Aadhaar, Aadhaar always wins

Related stories

A rain-scented walk in Sivagangai

Living on ravaged land

Biswas and the bamboos on his bike

Recycling energy, Godda style

Bhadels of Goa

Pookadai: still throbbing with morning life

Koli Kadlas

Malnourishment high among children of migrants: study

Wheels of the rural Indian West

Living Under a Red Cloud in Bellary

Vedla – earrings of the Maher community

Dreaming of water, drowning in debt

Kali: the dancer and his dreams

Farmer's diet worse than a convict's

In Yavatmal, life goes on

Suicides are about the living, not the dead

Death of a carpenter

Hoisa Shigmo!

Women farmers: weaving a life in Anantapur

Defiant in Dhinkia

Spice and all that's nice

Kerala's Green Army

The ‘jugaad’ not-a-mobile

Health as someone else's wealth

Calibrating in a Kudumbashree assembly unit